Who won, how much roster value changed hands, and what the scoreboard looks like if the trade never happened.
RJ Harvey to Nico’s Mail Order McBride; Chris Olave to Lizard King
Counterfactual score keeps each manager’s actual lineup-decision quality, then swaps only the trade-created roster-value difference. Regular-season and postseason rows are labeled separately. A flip means this first-order rewind changes that week’s result.
| Manager | Week | Phase | Actual | No trade | Roster Δ | Opponent | Opp. pts | Actual | No trade | Flip? |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Brent Holst | 12 | Regular | 146.05 | 152.80 | -6.75 | Jacob Carlson's Deepball | 144.82 | W | W | — |
| Brent Holst | 13 | Regular | 139.15 | 126.85 | +12.30 | Philadelphia Gregs | 104.65 | W | W | — |
| Brent Holst | 14 | Regular | 174.80 | 168.20 | +6.60 | Kory's Fat Cock | 179.35 | L | L | — |
| Brent Holst | 15 | Postseason | 241.75 | 241.75 | +0.00 | I Have Downs | 117.10 | W | W | — |
| Brent Holst | 16 | Postseason | 187.70 | 165.60 | +22.10 | Kory's Fat Cock | 151.80 | W | W | — |
| Brent Holst | 17 | Postseason | 177.70 | 167.50 | +10.20 | The Dunbear | 133.09 | W | W | — |
| Will Maness | 12 | Regular | 143.90 | 136.15 | +7.75 | Philadelphia Gregs | 145.20 | L | L | — |
| Will Maness | 13 | Regular | 136.10 | 142.60 | -6.50 | Dalvin and the Chimpmunks | 134.45 | W | W | — |
| Will Maness | 14 | Regular | 124.80 | 140.80 | -16.00 | Jonny lol | 145.28 | L | L | — |